USDA Plant Hardiness Zones vs RHS Ratings Explained

Understanding plant hardiness is essential for gardening success, and the two primary systems used globally are the USDA Plant Hardiness Zone Map and the Royal Horticultural Society (RHS) hardiness rating system. This article explores the fundamental differences between these two systems, focusing on how the USDA categorizes geographic regions by average extreme minimum temperatures, while the RHS rates the specific tolerance of individual plants to both cold and British growing conditions.

The USDA Plant Hardiness Zone Map

Developed by the United States Department of Agriculture, the USDA system is primarily a geographic mapping tool. It divides North America (and has been adapted for other parts of the world) into 13 distinct zones based on the average annual extreme minimum winter temperature.

  • Scale: Zones are numbered from 1 (coldest) to 13 (warmest).
  • Sub-zones: Each zone is divided into "a" and "b" increments, representing a 5-degree Fahrenheit difference (with the full zone representing a 10-degree difference).
  • Focus: The system strictly measures location-based climate data collected over a 30-year period. When a plant is labeled "hardy to Zone 5," it means the plant can survive the average lowest winter temperatures of that specific geographic zone.

The RHS Hardiness Rating System

Created by the Royal Horticultural Society in the United Kingdom, the RHS system is plant-centric rather than map-centric. Because the UK has a maritime climate with fewer temperature extremes but high variability in rainfall and humidity, the USDA system was often found to be less accurate for British gardeners.

  • Scale: Ratings go from H1 (requiring heated glass) to H7 (hardy in the severest European climates).
  • Sub-categories: The H1 category is broken down into H1a, H1b, and H1c to specify exact indoor heating requirements for tropical and subtropical plants.
  • Focus: Instead of assigning a zone to a location on a map, the RHS assigns an "H" rating to a specific plant based on the lowest temperatures it can endure, combined with practical descriptions of the environment it needs (such as "sheltered," "frost-free," or "sunny wall").

Key Differences Between the Two Systems

1. Geography vs. Plant Tolerance The most significant difference is what is being measured. The USDA system maps out the land first, and gardeners match plants to their map zone. The RHS system categorizes the plant first, telling the gardener what kind of winter conditions that specific plant can survive, regardless of where the gardener lives on a map.

2. Temperature Scale Direction The numerical scales run in opposite directions regarding cold tolerance. In the USDA system, a lower number means a colder climate (Zone 1 is sub-arctic). Therefore, a plant rated for Zone 2 is extremely cold-hardy. In the RHS system, a higher number indicates greater cold tolerance. An H7 plant is the most cold-hardy, capable of surviving temperatures colder than -20°C (-4°F), while an H1a plant must be kept in a heated greenhouse.

3. Inclusion of Microclimates and Growing Conditions The USDA map relies solely on air temperature data. It does not account for snow cover, freeze-thaw cycles, soil drainage, or wind. While the RHS system also uses minimum temperatures (measured in Celsius) as a baseline, its descriptions actively incorporate growing conditions. For example, an RHS rating of H4 notes that a plant is hardy for most of the UK, but explicitly warns that it may suffer foliage damage and requires shelter from cold winter winds and wet soil.

4. Indoor and Tropical Plants The USDA map is designed for outdoor gardening; Tropical plants simply fall into Zones 10 through 13. The RHS system directly addresses indoor and greenhouse gardening within its main scale. Ratings H1a through H2 specifically guide gardeners on how to manage tender plants that must be grown indoors year-round or moved into frost-free glasshouses during the winter.

Summary Comparison

To convert or compare the two, gardeners must look at the minimum temperatures each level represents, while remembering the inverted numbering. For example, the coldest RHS rating is H7 (colder than -20°C / -4°F), which roughly correlates to USDA Zones 6 and colder. Conversely, a warm USDA Zone 11 (above 4.4°C / 40°F) correlates with the RHS H1c or H2 ratings for tender plants. Ultimately, the USDA system tells you the climate of where you live, while the RHS system tells you the exact conditions a plant requires to survive.